Whatever the origins, the IOOF in this country was formed as a benevolent organization whose mission was (and still is) to “visit the sick, relieve the distressed, bury the dead and educate the orphan.” From 1860 to 1910/1920, the “Golden Age of Fraternalism” in America, the Odd Fellows became the largest among all fraternal organizations, even larger than Freemasonry. By 1889, the IOOF had lodges in every American state.

Local chapters began to form in the 1880s. There were 675 lodges in New York State in 1893, seven of them in Delaware County – Arkville, Arena, Roxbury, Delhi, Bloomville and Sidney. Ten years later, there were Lodges at Hancock, Grand Gorge, Walton and Davenport Center. By 1925, when there were 994 Lodges in the State, Stamford, Sidney Center, Trout Creek and Treadwell joined the Delaware District. That year, Arkville had 126 active members, Roxbury 87 and Arena 31.

The earliest membership book found at Brian Sweeney’s Arkville building, which was the meeting hall of Lodge #558, dates back to 1887. A book listing officers from 1889 through 1898 shows that on July 1, 1889, the following men held leadership positions in Lodge #558: A. B. Bookhout, B. L. Searles, C. E. Hood, S. Korn, H. R. Wait, W. H. Griffin, J. W. Redmond, V. Fuller, G. H. Dimmock, E. Redmond, W. W. Biehler, J. Kelly, James More, George Lasher and William Griffin.

In 1893, according to the proceedings of the Annual Session of the NYS State IOOF, W. W. Bassett was Grand Master in Arkville, and F. H. McLean held the same post in Arena, which had 64 members that year. Members advanced by “degrees,” which were conferred with ritual and pageantry. Ornate, silver- and brass-embroidered collars signifying rank and position were found in the Arkville hall, along with catalogues showing costumes, props and ceremonial items that Lodges could order.

Arkville books indicate that membership was $1 a year in the early years, $2 later. Funds were mostly utilized to maintain the building, and to provide “sick benefits” to ill members (in 1903, six members received a total of $51), and to help pay ”burial” expenses for deceased members ($50 was paid that year to the widow of one Arkville Odd Fellow). This may have been one reason why membership skyrocketed in those pre-Social Security and Medicare days.

The IOOF became the first national fraternity to accept both men and women when it formed the Daughters of Rebekah in 1851. It wasn’t until 1904 that Rebekah chapters were established in Delaware County – in Roxbury, Delhi and Walton. The next year, Arena followed suit. By 1925, there were active Rebekahs in 12 Delaware County communities, including Arkville.